Skip to content
Buying guideWater & Winter

Best Horse Water Troughs (2026): Poly, Galvanized and Rubbermaid Stock Tanks

The best horse water trough for your herd size: poly, galvanized and Rubbermaid stock tanks compared on gallons, height, drain plugs and warranty.

By Barn Gear ReviewPublished 9 min readHow we research
A black oval poly stock tank full of clear water beside a wooden fence in a green summer paddock

Affiliate disclosure: product links on this page go to Amazon or to the maker's own store. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you; links to makers' own stores earn us nothing. No retailer or brand sees our picks before they are published or has any say in them. How we choose.

For one or two horses, the horse water trough we would buy is the Rubbermaid BRUTE 50 gallon stock tank two-pack: two 52 by 31 inch structural foam tanks, made in the USA, with smooth surfaces and a 10 year limited warranty (per the Amazon listing), so each paddock gets its own tank or a pair sits side by side. For three or more horses, the 300 gallon BRUTE holds most of a week's water and has a protected 2 inch drain plug.

If you prefer steel, Behlen Country's galvanized oval tanks run from 71 to 294 gallons with a rolled rim and a drain plug on the 2 foot tall sizes, and its Farm Flex poly tanks come in 50 to 300 gallons with UV inhibitors and a three year warranty; both are sold at farm stores. We sized every pick against how much water a horse drinks, using extension figures, and compared height, drain, material and warranty from the makers.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1. Best overall

    Rubbermaid BRUTE Stock Tank (50 gal, 2-pack)

    Capacity: 50 gal each, pack of 2 · Material: Structural foam poly · Drain: Not stated for this size · Warranty: 10 years limited (per the Amazon listing)

  2. 2. Best for a herd

    Rubbermaid BRUTE Stock Tank (300 gal)

    Capacity: 300 gal · Material: Structural foam poly · Drain: 2 in, protected (per the Amazon listing) · Warranty: 10 years limited (per the Amazon listing)

  3. 3. Best flexible tank

    Tuff Stuff KMT50 Oval Tank (50 gal)

    Capacity: 50 gal · Material: Recycled LDPE, rubber-like (per the Amazon listing) · Drain: Not stated in the listing · Warranty: Not stated in the listing

  4. 4. Best mid-size poly tank

    Behlen Country Farm Flex Oval Poly Tank

    Capacity: 50 to 300 gal (oval line) · Material: Flexible poly, UV inhibitors · Drain: 1 1/4 in poly plug · Warranty: 3 years

  5. 5. Best galvanized tank

    Behlen Country Farmstead Galvanized Oval Stock Tank

    Capacity: 71 to 294 gal (2 ft tall sizes) · Material: Galvanized steel, rolled rim · Drain: 3/8 in ratchet-compatible plug (2 ft tanks) · Warranty: 1 year

Two 50 gallon BRUTE tanks for owners with one or two horses: easy to tip and scrub, and one can be refilled while the other stays in use.

Capacity
50 gal each, pack of 2
Material
Structural foam poly
Drain
Not stated for this size
Warranty
10 years limited (per the Amazon listing)
Size
52 x 31 x 12 in (Rubbermaid)

Pros

  • Made in the USA, per Rubbermaid; 10 year limited warranty, per the listing
  • Smooth tank surfaces with no sharp edges and built-in body stiffeners, per the listing
  • At 12 inches tall, a 50 gallon tank is light enough to tip out and scrub

Cons

  • Rubbermaid's listing calls the 12 inch depth ideal for smaller animals, and each tank holds about 4 days of water for one idle horse
  • Rubbermaid does not state a drain plug for the 50 gallon size on the page we read

Rubbermaid lists the 50 gallon BRUTE tank (FG424300BLA) at 52 by 31 inches and 12 inches tall, and says its BRUTE stock tanks are made in the USA and provide a water source for livestock including horses. The Amazon listing for this pack of two adds structural foam construction, built-in body stiffeners, a ribbed base, no sharp surfaces and a 10 year limited warranty.

Fifty gallons is about four days of water for one idle horse drinking 12 gallons a day, and two days for two horses, less in summer heat when extension services say the need can double. That is the case for the two-pack: one tank per paddock, or two side by side so there is always water while one is being cleaned.

Skip it for a group of three or more; you will be refilling daily. The 300 gallon BRUTE is the herd size.

A 300 gallon BRUTE for three or more horses, with a 2 inch drain plug protected by the tank walls.

Capacity
300 gal
Material
Structural foam poly
Drain
2 in, protected (per the Amazon listing)
Warranty
10 years limited (per the Amazon listing)
Size
63 x 69 x 25 in (Rubbermaid)

Pros

  • Oversized 2 inch drain plug protected by surrounding walls, per the listing
  • 25 inches tall: room for a floating or sinking de-icer in winter
  • Made in the USA, per Rubbermaid

Cons

  • 80 lb and 63 by 69 inches (per the listing and Rubbermaid): plan where it goes before delivery
  • Too much water for one horse to turn over before it gets stale in warm weather

Rubbermaid lists the 300 gallon BRUTE (FG424700BLA) at 63 by 69 inches and 25 inches tall. The Amazon listing adds an oversized 2 inch drain plug protected by surrounding walls, structural foam construction and a 10 year limited warranty.

For four horses drinking 12 gallons each, 300 gallons is about six days of water; in summer or with horses in work, closer to three. In winter, a tank this size needs a 1,500 watt de-icer by API's general guidance for 100 to 300 gallons; see our trough heater guide. Rubbermaid also makes a drain-plug de-icer for its 100 to 300 gallon tanks.

A 50 gallon oval tub in recycled, rubber-like plastic that the listing describes as flexible and impact resistant.

Capacity
50 gal
Material
Recycled LDPE, rubber-like (per the Amazon listing)
Drain
Not stated in the listing
Warranty
Not stated in the listing

Pros

  • 100% recycled LDPE flexible plastic with a rubber-like quality, per the listing
  • Impact resistant, per the listing

Cons

  • Few published specs: no drain, warranty or dimensions on the listing we could confirm with the maker
  • 50 gallons suits one or two horses only

Tuff Stuff's KMT50 is a 50 gallon oval tank made from 100% recycled LDPE that the listing describes as flexible with a rubber-like quality, and impact resistant. We could not find a Tuff Stuff spec page for this model, so the figures are the listing's.

It is the pick for a paddock where a tank gets pushed, pawed or kicked. For more water, pair it with a second tank or step up to a larger poly tank.

Behlen's flexible poly tanks in 100, 125 and 150 gallon sizes fill the gap between the Rubbermaid picks.

Capacity
50 to 300 gal (oval line)
Material
Flexible poly, UV inhibitors
Drain
1 1/4 in poly plug
Warranty
3 years

Pros

  • Sizes of 50, 65, 70, 100, 125, 150 and 300 gallons, per Behlen
  • Heavy-duty drain fitting with a 1 1/4 inch poly plug and UV inhibitors, per Behlen
  • Flexible poly with smooth, rounded edges that Behlen says resists impact, corrosion and leaks

Cons

  • Behlen recommends the included braces on oval tanks over 100 gallons to limit bowing
  • Sold through farm stores

Behlen Country's Farm Flex oval tanks come in 50, 65, 70, 100, 125, 150 and 300 gallon sizes, in flexible poly with reinforced sidewalls, smooth rounded edges, UV inhibitors and a heavy-duty drain fitting with a 1 1/4 inch poly plug. Behlen gives them a three year warranty and recommends fitting the included braces on oval tanks over 100 gallons.

A 100 to 150 gallon tank suits two to four horses: 100 gallons is about four days for two horses at 12 gallons each. Behlen sells it through farm stores.

A zinc-coated steel oval tank with a rolled rim and a drain plug, in sizes from 71 to 294 gallons on the 2 foot tall line.

Capacity
71 to 294 gal (2 ft tall sizes)
Material
Galvanized steel, rolled rim
Drain
3/8 in ratchet-compatible plug (2 ft tanks)
Warranty
1 year

Pros

  • Behlen publishes exact capacities and dimensions for every size, from 2x2x3 (71 gal) to 3x2x8 (294 gal)
  • Rolled rim top edge and vertical corrugations for strength, per Behlen
  • Steel takes a floating de-icer without the guard API requires for some floaters in plastic tanks

Cons

  • One year warranty, against 3 to 10 years for the poly picks
  • Steel can dent, and the zinc coating is what keeps it from rusting

Behlen's Farmstead oval tanks are all-steel with a zinc coating, a rolled rim top edge and vertical corrugations, and the 2 foot tall sizes have a 3/8 inch ratchet-compatible drain plug. Behlen's sizing chart lists them at 23.5 inches tall: 2x2x4 at 103 gallons, 2x2x6 at 169 gallons, 2x2x8 at 224 gallons and 3x2x8 at 294 gallons, among others. All its galvanized tanks carry a one year warranty.

Galvanized suits owners who want a rigid tank that will not bow when full and who plan on a floating de-icer: API requires a metal guard for some of its floating models in plastic or Rubbermaid tanks, which a steel tank avoids. Priefert, another maker, describes its galvanized horse tanks as having smooth rolled rims and sealed seams; the rim is the detail to check on any steel tank.

How we chose

We sized troughs against what horses drink, then compared capacity, height, material, drain plug and warranty from the makers' pages and the makers' or Amazon's own listings, marked where used. The two Behlen Country picks are sold through farm stores, and we link to Behlen.

How big a trough do your horses need?

The University of Kentucky's article for the national Extension horse network puts a mature idle horse of about 1,100 lb at 10 to 12 gallons a day, and says the need doubles in hot weather or hard work and rises 50 to 70% for a lactating mare. The University of Tennessee gives 10 to 12 gallons for a 1,000 lb horse. Using 12 gallons per horse:

Days of water from a full trough at 12 gallons per horse per day (our arithmetic; halve it in hot weather or hard work)
Trough1 horse2 horses4 horses
50 gal4 days2 days1 day
100 gal8 days4 days2 days
150 gal12 days6 days3 days
300 gal25 days12 days6 days

Bigger is not automatically better. A tank that one horse takes three weeks to empty goes a long time between natural refills and cleanings, and Kentucky stresses frequent cleaning of water containers so horses do not drink what has fallen in. We would size a tank to last two to five days between fills and scrub it at each refill.

Poly, galvanized or Rubbermaid-style

MaterialWhat the makers claimWatch for
Structural foam (Rubbermaid BRUTE)Weather, impact and corrosion resistant; smooth surfaces; 10 year limited warranty (listing)Some floating de-icers need a metal guard in these tanks (API)
Flexible poly (Behlen Farm Flex, Tuff Stuff)No rust or dents; flexes under impact; UV inhibitors (Behlen)Large ovals can bow; Behlen supplies braces over 100 gal
Galvanized steel (Behlen Farmstead, Priefert)Zinc coating, rolled rim, corrugated for strengthShorter warranty (1 year at Behlen); dents

What to look for

Height

The Rubbermaid 50 gallon tank is 12 inches tall; the 100 and 300 gallon BRUTE tanks and Behlen's 2 foot galvanized line are about 2 feet. Taller tanks hold more water on the same footprint and leave room for a de-icer, while shallow ones are easier to tip out and clean.

Drain plug

A drain lets you empty a tank for cleaning without bailing. Rubbermaid's 100 and 300 gallon tanks have a protected 2 inch drain, Behlen's 2 foot galvanized tanks a 3/8 inch ratchet-compatible plug and Farm Flex tanks a 1 1/4 inch poly plug. A drain also opens up drain-plug de-icers, which API says need a hole of 3/4 inch or larger.

Winter

Tennessee advises defrosting unheated troughs at least twice a day and notes that snow and ice are not adequate water for horses. Match your tank to a de-icer before winter: API's general guidance is 500 watts under 70 gallons, 1,000 watts for 70 to 100 gallons and 1,500 watts for 100 to 300 gallons. Our horse trough heater guide covers floating, sinking and drain-plug types.

Placement

Set a trough on level ground where you can reach it with a hose and, in winter, an outlet an electrician has installed for a de-icer.

What to skip

  • A huge tank for one horse. It stays full for weeks and gets dirty; buy two smaller tanks instead.
  • Tanks with no stated capacity or drain. You need both numbers to plan refills and cleaning.
  • Floating de-icers in plastic tanks without checking the manual. API requires a metal guard for some models.
  • Relying on snow in a frozen trough. Tennessee says snow and ice are not adequate water sources.

Tired of filling troughs? An automatic horse waterer refills itself, and for stalls see our heated water bucket guide.

Frequently asked questions

What size water trough do I need for two horses?

At the 10 to 12 gallons a day extension services give for an idle horse, two horses drink about 24 gallons a day. A 50 gallon tank lasts about two days and a 100 gallon tank about four, half that in hot weather or hard work. For two horses, 50 to 150 gallons gives two to six days between fills.

Is a poly or galvanized trough better for horses?

Both work. Poly tanks like Rubbermaid's BRUTE and Behlen's Farm Flex do not rust and carry 3 to 10 year warranties; galvanized steel tanks like Behlen's Farmstead are rigid with a rolled rim but carry a one year warranty at Behlen and can dent. Check the de-icer you plan to use, since some floating models need a guard in plastic tanks.

How much water does a horse drink a day?

The University of Kentucky's extension article puts a mature idle horse of about 1,100 lb at 10 to 12 gallons a day. The need doubles in hot weather or hard work, and lactating mares need 50 to 70% more.

How often should you clean a horse water trough?

Often enough that nothing builds up; the University of Kentucky stresses frequent cleaning of water containers so horses do not drink debris. Sizing a tank to last two to five days between fills and scrubbing it at each refill keeps it manageable, and a drain plug makes that much easier.

Do I need a trough with a drain plug?

It makes cleaning much easier and lets you use a drain-plug de-icer. Rubbermaid's 100 and 300 gallon tanks have a protected 2 inch drain, Behlen's 2 foot galvanized tanks a 3/8 inch plug and Farm Flex tanks a 1 1/4 inch plug. API's drain-plug de-icers need a hole of at least 3/4 inch.

Sources

  1. BRUTE Stock Tanks, Rubbermaid Commercial Products
  2. Farmstead Oval Stock Tanks, Behlen Country
  3. Farm Flex Oval Tanks, Behlen Country
  4. Tank Sizing, Behlen Country
  5. Horses and Water, University of Kentucky, Extension Horses
  6. Winter Management, University of Tennessee, UT Horse
  7. API De-Icers: What's the Difference?, Miller Manufacturing
  8. Priefert Equine Products Catalog, Priefert

Cover image: Illustration: Barn Gear Review (AI-generated)

Share this article

Water & WinterWater TroughsStock TanksHorse WaterPaddock GearWinter Horse Care